Childhood101

playing. learning. growing.

  • Learning Activities
    • Mathematics
    • Literacy
    • Social Emotional Learning
    • Distance Learning Resources
    • Coding for Kids
    • Science & Nature
    • Art & Craft
    • Holidays/Celebrations
    • Best Books for Kids
    • Products We Love
  • Play Ideas
    • Group Games for Kids
    • Sensory Play Ideas
    • Outdoor Play
    • Fun Play Spaces
    • Pretend Play
    • Lego Challenges
  • PRINTABLES
  • Books for Kids
    • Picture Books
    • Chapter Books
    • Graphic Novels
  • Activities By Age
    • School Age Learners
    • Pre+K Learners
    • Toddler Play
    • Baby Play
  • SHOP

Friendship: Developing Sharing Behaviour

Consider the following two sharing scenarios;

1. A child is playing with a toy. Another child sees and wants the toy too. An adult intervenes, saying to the first child, “Billy, you can have a turn for two minutes and then we will let Abbie have a turn.” The adults waits with the children and after two minutes oversees the transaction of the toy from one child to the other.  She then verbally praises Billy for his good sharing.

2. A child is playing with a toy. Another child sees and wants the toy too. An adult intervenes, saying to the second child, “Abbie, when Billy is done playing with the xx, you can have a turn.”
She then turns to Billy and says, “Billy, when you’re done could you please let Abbie know so that she can have a turn.”
The adult then helps to distract Abbie to another activity nearby while she waits.
Shortly after Billy passes the toy to Abbie and the adult notices and positively reinforces his generous behaviour by saying, “Thank you Billy for remembering that Abbie was waiting for a turn and passing the toy to her.”

Which of these scenarios is more effective in developing a child’s intrinsic sharing behaviour? Which would have the most satisfactory outcome for Billy who first had ownership of the toy? Why? What lessons is each child learning from each scenario?

It is unreasonable to think that children younger than four or five years of age have the social skills necessary to share independently and so it is natural that as adults we support young children in their playful interactions. However how we choose to intervene has influence beyond a few minutes of conflict or upset in the here and now. It is good to remind ourselves that simple, subtle changes in our words and actions encourage the development of longer term, self-motivated behaviours for our child.

A useful resource for parents wanting to help their children develop positive, intrinsically motivated behaviours is Parenting With Positive Guidance: Tools for Building Discipline from the Inside Out, an e-book by Amanda Morgan (this is an affiliate link).

Related Posts

  • Friendship: Children Developing Empathy
  • Can We Love Our Children Too Much?
  • Strategies to Bullyproof Our Kids

{Image source}

Christie Burnett is a teacher, presenter, writer and the mother of two. She created Childhood 101 as a place for teachers and parents to access engaging, high quality learning ideas.

Filed Under: Developing Emotionally, Developing Socially Tagged With: social development

Previous post: The Friendship of New Mums
Next post: Organising Kids Spaces: Our Book Corner

Read the comments or scroll down to add your own:

  1. Melissa says

    May 12, 2011 at 7:43 AM

    Thanks for this article, as a mother of a toddler, the whole sharing concept is very relevant. I do sometimes wonder why as parents we put such an emphasis on learning to share? Just a thought I've been having lately observing my own son. I wonder sometimes if we do this backwards, that maybe we should be teaching kids they can't just have everything they want nor take that toy off another child . Isn't it up to the child with the toy to decide whether he wants to share 'his' toy or not, after all, isn't that's part of what ownership is all about (I know this is a little different in a preschool type setting). We spend so much time telling our kids that 'this is for mummy, not you, no touching' but then tell them they have to share their stuff. Anyway, it's just a thought I've been having lately. Love your website by the way, very glad I found it.
    • Christie Burnett says

      May 12, 2011 at 7:58 AM

      Thanks for your comment, Melissa, I am hoping that this post gets parents thinking about this very idea :) My three year old's current response to being told she can't have something is, "But you have to share, Mummy!"
      • Melissa says

        May 12, 2011 at 11:24 AM

        LOL, that's very cute!
  2. Min says

    May 12, 2011 at 8:19 AM

    I follow the second and it's always amazing how easily kids share when given a choice!
  3. Natalie says

    May 12, 2011 at 10:28 PM

    I also follow the second strategy, and it's funny how often the second kid doesn't want the toy any longer when distracted by something else. On the other hand, quite often then the first kid wants to have what the other one is having :)
    • Lisa Sunbury says

      May 13, 2011 at 2:19 AM

      What a great observation! In my experience, there may be a couple of reasons for this: First, it's not about the toy- it's about the relationship. Toddlers and preschoolers are interested in other people, and just learning how to interact in socially acceptable ways with peers. The toy becomes the medium through which they are communicating. Also, ever notice how a toy or an object seems to "come alive" in someone else's hands? To children, toys aren't as interesting when they are just sitting there, but they become animated when another child is using them, which is why you can have three toys of the exact same kind sitting there, but three children will be interested in the one that someone else is using. In my work with toddlers, I also use the second method, but I give children even more space to work things out on their own, as long as no one is getting hurt. I really trust toddlers to work things out in a way that is acceptable to them, without feeling the need to impose my standards or ideas about sharing. A lot of times, just moving close to the children involved in a struggle and narrating what I see happening is all that's needed to help them problem solve. "You both want that truck. Billy is using it, and Abbie you want to use it too. Abbie you are pulling on the truck, and Billy is saying NO!" Then I wait. If more support is needed, I might point out that there is another truck nearby, or ask the children how they think they can solve the problem (if they're verbal). But I stop short of asking one child to give the other a turn, and I don't try to distract the child who might be upset about having to wait, or losing the toy, because to me it's all about children having the opportunity to learn about how to be in relationship with others.
      • Gill@Alice Becomes says

        May 22, 2011 at 8:14 AM

        This is an excellent point. I am trying to narrate what is happening with my children's behavior more, I find it more effective that passing judgement eg "Good Boy, Well Done, Great Jump" etc. I haven't thought of doing it when there are disagreements, I will give it a shot today!
    • Christie Burnett says

      May 15, 2011 at 8:05 AM

      That is so true!
  4. Laura Oreamuno says

    May 21, 2011 at 10:33 PM

    I think the second choice is better, the first player can continue without feeling guilty, the second gets company while waiting and both at their own page finally share the toy and the empathy. I´ve done the first example too, but mostly when things get so difficult that the adult "decides" instead of suggest.Laura Oreamuno San Jose, Costa Rica. Central America
Welcome
pinterestinstagramteachers pay teachersyoutubefacebook

Search

Tips & Resources


Latest

65+ YA dystopian books for teens

21 Thrilling YA Dystopian Book Series for Teens

Inside: Our pick of the best YA dystopian books series for teens. If your … [Read More...]

2023 Kids Calendar Printable

Free, Printable Kids Calendar 2023 with Mindful Affirmations

Help your tween or teen stay on top of school tasks and out-of-school … [Read More...]

Best Family Games for you New Years Eve Party

10 Best Family Games for Your New Year’s Eve Party

Looking for a range of fun, high energy family games to play at your New Year's … [Read More...]

The Book

Learning Resources


Activities by Age

Baby
Toddler
Preschool
School-age
Family

Copyright ©2022 · Childhood101 - All Rights Reserved ·

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • PRIVACY POLICY